MEAL REPLACEMENT DRINKS
It seems that every other person is on a diet. Many people ask me about
meal replacement drinks, which have become a part of the dieting scene.
These can be helpful for weight-loss, weight-gain, detoxification,
improving digestion, building muscle and athletic performance. Below I
have compared 6 professional products and 12 commercial products. For
more information, you can access websites for each of these.
PROFESSIONAL PRODUCTS
Professional products are made by companies that sell to licensed
health-care providers only. These are usually to aid in detoxification,
improve digestion, or to speed
weight-loss. They aspire to be hypoallergenic, meaning they do not
contain dairy, gluten, egg, soy, corn, dyes, or synthetic additives.
Most are made with rice protein to avoid common food allergens, or
isolated soy or milk proteins (pre-digested). Most contain the basic 28
vitamins and minerals. Many contain glutamine to improve digestion, or
glutathione to improve liver detoxification, or other therapeutic
agents, plus antioxidants. The added ingredients improve the effect of
these products, but raise the price. Most of these are sold in cans of
20 - 21 servings; Pure Encapsulations are sold in cans for 13 or 15
servings.
PROFESSIONAL MEAL REPLACEMENT DRINKS
In Alphabetical Order
PRODUCT:
Protein
Powders |
PROTEIN BASE |
ADDED
NUTRIENTS |
CALORIES
Per Serving |
PROTEIN
In Grams |
COST for
3 WEEKS:
20-21 servings |
Isolean
Xymogen
** |
Rice or
Soy or
Whey,
Isolated Proteins
Flavors. |
Vitamins
Minerals
Olive Oil
Glutamine
Lysine
Threonine
Enzymes
Antioxidants |
170 - 186 |
21 grams |
$60 retail for 21 days.
Discounted 25% at Clinic
= $45
|
IsoProtein Plus
By Pure Encapsulations |
Soy isolate
Flavors |
Vitamin C
Minerals
Herbs
Stevia |
174 |
21 grams |
$63 retail for 20 days. |
Mediclear
By Thorne
** |
Rice |
28 Vitamins
& Minerals
Glutathione
Glutamine
NAC, TMG
Borage Oil
Quercetin
MSM & more. |
180 |
25 grams |
$47 retail for 20 days.
Discounted 25% at Clinic
= $35 |
Pro Basic
By Pure Encapsulations |
Whey
Rice
Flavors. |
Vitamin C
Minerals
Herbs
Stevia |
152 |
31 grams |
$48 retail for 20 days. |
Ultraclear
Macro
By Metagenics |
Rice |
Limited
vitamins & minerals |
150 |
15 grams |
$47 retail for 20 days. |
Ultraclear Plus
Medical Food
By Metagenics |
Rice |
Vitamins
Minerals
Glutathione |
160 |
15 grams |
$75 retail for 20 days. |
** Sold by Allergy & Nutrition Clinic
COMMERCIAL PRODUCTS
Commercial meal replacement drinks are sold in stores and online. These
are used for
multiple purposes. Those for weight loss contain less calories; while
those for weight
gain have more calories. Those used for muscle building or athletic
performance contain
very high protein content and more calories. Some are protein powders in
cans or packets; others are single-use drinks for convenience. Many of
these are available with
"packages", energy bars, antioxidant drinks, or other health or
weight-loss
products, or even pre-packaged meals. Ingredients vary considerably, but
usually contain some vitamins and minerals. Some even contain organic,
kosher or isolated proteins; while others contain antioxidants.
Undesirable ingredients include: sulfites, corn syrup, dyes, artificial
flavors, Splenda (sucralose, chlorinated table sugar), wheat or oat
(gluten), and assorted fillers - which are highlighted in red.
COMMERCIAL MEAL REPLACEMENT DRINKS
In Alphabetical Order
PRODUCT:
Protein
Powders |
PROTEIN BASE |
ADDED
NUTRIENTS |
CALORIES
Per Serving |
PROTEIN
In Grams |
COST for
3 WEEKS:
20-21 servings |
Advantage
By Atkins |
Milk
Soy,
Drink
Flavors. |
18 nutrients Borage Oil or Flax Oil
Sulfites |
170 |
20 grams |
$41
|
Boost
By Mead & Johnson |
Milk,
Drink
Flavors. |
Corn Syrup,
Veg Oil,
Vitamins
Minerals
Etc. |
240 |
15 grams |
$27 |
Ensure Plus
By Abbott Labs |
Soy Isolate
Drink
Flavors. |
Vitamins
Minerals
Antioxidants
Corn Syrup
Oils,
Dyes
Art. Flavors |
350 |
13 grams |
$24 |
GNC brand shakes
By GNC |
Milk
Soy
Corn
Powder |
Vitamins
Minerals
Sucralose (chlorinated sugar) |
180 |
9 grams |
$40 |
IsaLean Shake
By Isagenix International
*** |
Organic Whey &
Soy
Milk casein
Powder
Flavors |
12 vitamins and minerals, herbs, and antioxidants |
240 |
23 grams |
$67 retail for 20 days.
$52 whsle from Dottie McKee with membership. |
Isopure
By Nature's Best |
Pure
Whey Isolate
(clear liquid) |
Nothing - a pure protein, predigested. |
160 |
40 grams |
$30 |
Lean Body MRP Shake
(Original)
By Labrada Nutrition |
Whey Concen,
Soy Isolate,
Milk Isolate,
Gluten
Flavors.
20 Packets |
Vitamins
Minerals
Glutamine
Oils
Sucralose
(chlorinated sugar) |
330 |
40 grams |
$62 |
Medifast 55 Shakes
By Medifast1 |
Soy Isolate, Kosher Dairy Iosolate.
6 Flavors. |
24 Vitamins & Minerals.
Low lactose,
Oat & wheat. |
90 |
11 grams |
$41 |
Myoplex
By EAS |
Whey
Egg
Milk casein
Powder.
Flavors. |
Vitamins
Minerals
Fillers |
270 |
42 grams |
$62 |
Rice Protein
By NutriBiotic
**
Sold to health food stores & professionals. |
Rice |
None |
116 |
24 grams |
$15 retail for 20 days.
Discounted 25% at Clinic
= $12 |
Spirutein
By Nature's Plus |
Soy &
Spirulina
(blue-green algae)
15 Flavors. |
Vitamins
Minerals |
99 |
14 grams |
$21 |
Sustain
By Designer Nutrition |
Casein & Whey Isolate
|
Inulin |
105 |
20 grams |
$20 |
** Sold by Allergy & Nutrition Clinic
*** Sold by: www.dotsdetox.isagenix.com